Best Investors Account Sign in

Info / FAQ / Advisor red flags

Advisor red flags

Stop for a promised return, a check payable to the person, or a rollover pushed before a written cost comparison. Then read Item 9A and Item 11.

The short answer

Stop when the pitch and the paperwork disagree. A promised return, a check payable to the adviser as a person, or pressure to roll a 401(k) before you have a written cost comparison are reasons to pause. So is a firm you cannot find on Form ADV. Item 11 is a disclosure to read, not a score. Item 9A is the custody answer, and it should match the statements you actually receive.

One flag is a question. Two flags, unanswered in writing, are a reason to leave the money where it is until you understand them.

Stop and ask, in writingThe document that should answer
A stated or "targeted" returnThe brochure. It should not promise a result.
"Make the check out to me"The custodian name on the transfer form
"Roll the 401(k) this week"A written comparison of staying or moving. See the rollover page.
No Form ADV, or "we're exempt, don't look"The firm on IAPD
Statements only from the adviserA statement from the custodian. Who holds the money
Item 11 has a YesHow to read Item 11. Then ask what happened.
A fiduciary badge and a refusal to write the sentenceThe email on the fiduciary check

What to do

  1. Open the firm on Search before the second meeting. If you cannot find the firm, ask for the CRD, the ID number, and look it up on IAPD yourself. A missing firm is the first flag.
  2. Read Item 11 far enough to see whether any disclosure box is Yes. A Yes is not an automatic no. It is a paragraph you ask them to explain. A blank Item 11 is not a medal.
  3. Read Item 9A and compare it to the company name on your latest statement, or on the sample statement they show you. If they will not show a sample, ask why.
  4. Look at any form that moves money. The payee is the custodian or the fund company, for your account. Your name is the account holder. The adviser's personal name is not the payee.
  5. If the meeting turns to a 401(k), ask for the comparison in writing before you sign: costs if you stay, costs if you move, and what you give up. Pressure to sign in the room is the flag. The form can wait until tomorrow.
  6. Write one email that lists the flags you saw and the sentence you need back. A clear reply retires the flag. Silence, or a joke, keeps it.

What to look for on Best Investors

  • Item 11 clusters. Criminal disclosures, regulatory disclosures, and a termination of a license are different boxes. Read the group that is Yes. Do not average them into a vibe.
  • Item 9A(1)(a) and 9A(1)(b). Cash and securities are separate. A firm can describe fee deduction in the brochure and still need to match the statement name.
  • Item 5E(5) and Item 6A. Commissions and a broker-dealer business are conflicts to read, not secret codes for fraud. The flag is a person who will not say which account pays a commission.
  • The brochure date. An old PDF that does not match the pitch is a flag. Download the current brochure from IAPD if ours is missing.

Common mistakes

  • Treating a polished office as the opposite of a flag. The documents are the test.
  • Treating any Item 11 mark as proof the firm is dishonest. Some disclosures are old, narrow, or about a different person. Ask. Also do not ignore them because the lunch was pleasant.
  • Confusing a market loss with a missing account. Losses happen in real funds. A statement that never comes from a custodian is the other problem.
  • Signing a rollover because the adviser said the plan fees are "high" without writing the numbers. High compared with what, in dollars?
  • Collecting flags and then sending the transfer the same afternoon because you already told your family you were moving.

Related questions

Is a guaranteed return always a fraud?

It is a reason to stop and read. An adviser cannot honestly promise what a market will do. A bank deposit, an insurance product, or a Treasury has its own terms, and those terms are in a document, not in a percentage spoken at dinner. Ask which product, and who issues it.

What if Item 11 is blank?

You still have the rest of the list. A blank disclosure section means the firm reported no Yes on those items. It does not price the fee, name the custodian, or make the person a fiduciary. Keep going through Item 5E, Item 9A, and BrokerCheck.

Should I confront them in the lobby?

Send the email. You want their words in a file. If the situation is that a check was already made out to a person, call the custodian and your bank before you write a review. The email can follow.

Are high fees a red flag?

A fee you do not understand is a question. A fee that is large next to the work is a reason to get another quote, which is the 1% page. Fraud is the payable-to line and the missing statement, not a percent you simply dislike.

Limits

This page is a stop list. It is not a finding that any firm committed fraud, and it is not legal advice. Best Investors is not the SEC or FINRA.

Item 11 and Item 9A are what the firm reported. Those answers are self-reported. We do not investigate complaints or audit accounts. A flag here means "get the document," not "we have judged this firm."

If our copy and IAPD disagree, use IAPD. For a broker record, use BrokerCheck.

Sources

Other FAQ articles