Best Investors
Sign in
Best Investors
Sign in
Form ADV Part 1A Item 8A(1) · Answer type: yn · Item 8 - Participation or Interest in Client Transactions
Item 8A(1) asks whether the adviser buys securities for itself from advisory clients, or sells securities it owns to advisory clients: known as principal transactions where the adviser firm acts as the counterparty to client trades rather than simply facilitating transactions in the market.
In the transaction asked about here, the adviser owns the security sold to the client or buys a security from the client for itself. The adviser is the client's counterparty rather than only arranging a trade with someone else.
Principal transactions create inherent conflicts because the adviser's interests as a trader (getting the best price for their own inventory) can conflict with their fiduciary duty to get the best execution and pricing for their advisory clients. The firm might have incentives to sell securities to clients at higher prices or buy from clients at lower prices to benefit their trading profits.
An adviser that occasionally buys municipal bonds from clients into their own inventory or sells bonds from their inventory to clients would mark Yes. An adviser that only facilitates client trades in external markets without taking the other side would mark No.
Yes
The adviser engages in principal transactions, trading securities directly with clients from the firm's own inventory or purchasing securities into their inventory from clients. SEC rules require specific disclosure and consent procedures for these transactions to manage the inherent conflicts of interest.
No
The firm reports No and does not report the principal transactions described by 8A(1). This answer does not describe every other execution or cross-transaction arrangement.
8A(1) - Buy securities for yourself from advisory clients, or sell securities you own to advisory clients (principal transactions) (Yes / No).
This checkbox is part of Item 8A, which covers situations where the adviser has participation or interests that could conflict with client transactions.
Principal transactions create direct conflicts where the adviser's profit on inventory trades can conflict with getting clients the best prices. A Yes answer means you should understand how the firm manages these conflicts and ensures fair pricing.
When advisers engage in principal trading, they must follow strict SEC rules requiring disclosure of their role as principal, client consent to the conflict, and fair pricing. However, even compliant principal transactions can result in clients paying more or receiving less than they might in open market transactions.
A Yes does not tell you how frequently principal transactions occur, what types of securities are involved, how the firm determines fair pricing, whether clients consistently get competitive prices, or what controls exist to prevent conflicts from affecting client outcomes.
Request the firm's principal-transaction disclosure and consent procedure. For any proposed trade, compare the quoted price with an available market price and confirm whether the firm or a related person is the counterparty.
Yes
The adviser reports engaging in principal transactions. On Best Investors, find Item 8 on the firm’s ADV form panel and confirm 8A(1) is Yes. Review the full Item 8A participation section and 6A(1) broker-dealer activities on the same profile for related trading conflicts.
For any principal trade offered to you, identify the security, the firm's role as counterparty, the quoted price, an available market comparison, and the consent document.
No
The firm reports No under 8A(1). Still review neighboring Item 8 rows on the Best Investors ADV panel, including brokerage practices and soft dollars, for other reported execution arrangements.