Best Investors
Sign in
Best Investors
Sign in
Form ADV Part 1A Item 8C(4) · Answer type: yn · Item 8 - Brokerage Practices
Item 8C(4) asks whether the firm has discretionary authority to determine the commission rates paid by clients on securities transactions: meaning the adviser can negotiate or accept different commission levels without requiring client pre-approval for each rate.
Discretionary commission rate authority means the adviser can accept varying commission structures from different brokers, negotiate rates based on trade volume or relationship value, or choose execution venues with different cost structures based on their assessment of overall value including execution quality and additional services.
This authority can create conflicts because advisers might accept higher commission rates in exchange for research, technology, or other soft dollar benefits that primarily benefit the adviser's business rather than focusing solely on minimizing client trading costs.
An adviser who negotiates commission rates across multiple brokers and can accept different rates based on value analysis would mark Yes. An adviser who only executes trades at rates predetermined by clients would mark No.
Yes
The adviser has discretionary authority to determine commission rates for client transactions. This requires them to balance execution costs against execution quality and additional services while managing conflicts that might favor higher-cost arrangements.
No
The adviser does not have discretionary authority over commission rates. Commission levels are likely predetermined by clients or fixed through specific arrangements that limit the adviser's flexibility.
8C(4) - Commission rates to be paid to a broker or dealer for a client's securities transactions (Yes / No).
This checkbox is part of Item 8C, which covers discretionary authority over various aspects of client brokerage activities.
Commission discretion can create conflicts where advisers might accept higher costs to obtain benefits for their own operations rather than minimizing client expenses. A Yes answer means you should understand their commission practices and cost management policies.
When advisers control commission rates, they might pay higher rates to obtain research or services, favor brokers offering soft dollar benefits, or fail to negotiate aggressively on client behalf to maintain broker relationships that benefit the adviser.
A Yes does not tell you the rates clients actually pay, whether those rates beat open-market alternatives, how often the firm renegotiates, or whether soft-dollar research offsets higher commissions in a way that benefits your account.
Request the commission schedule and the factors used in the firm's commission-rate review. Check 8C(3) for broker-selection authority and 8G(1) for reported soft dollar benefits.
Yes
The adviser reports commission rate discretion. On Best Investors, find Item 8C on the firm’s ADV form panel and confirm 8C(4) is Yes. Also review 8G(1) soft dollar benefits on the same panel to see if research or other broker benefits might influence commission decisions, and skim neighboring Item 8 rows for related brokerage conflicts.
No
The adviser does not report commission rate discretion. Commission structures are more likely predetermined or client-directed, which can limit conflicts over rate decisions: but still check 8C(3) broker selection and Item 8 soft dollars for related cost drivers.